Thursday, 26 May 2022

UN dismisses North Korea’s claim that damning human

UN dismisses North Korea’s claim that damning human Shin Dong-hyuk admitted this week that elements of his bestselling gulag survivor book, Escape from Camp 14, were inaccurate. Photograph: Chip Somodevilla/Getty
The head of the UN commission that produced a damning report on North Korean rights abuses
has dismissed Pyongyang’s claim that doubts about the credibility of a prominent witness made the panel’s findings invalid.
“The partial retraction of Shin Dong-hyuk of the testimony he gave to the Commission of Inquiry on North Korea is not significant for the report, conclusions or recommendations of the commission,” said retired Australian judge Michael Kirby.
Shin, a well-known defector and Pyongyang critic, admitted this week that elements of his bestselling gulag survivor book Escape from Camp 14 were inaccurate, though he stressed that the crucial details of his suffering and torture still stood.
For his part, Kirby noted that Shin was only one of 300 witnesses interviewed by his commission, whose overall findings were based on a mass of “overwhelming” corroborative evidence.
“The dispute over Shin’s evidence appears to relate to the exact detention camp from which he escaped,” Kirby said. “In the big picture of gross abuses of human rights of the entire population of North Korea over more than 65 years, his experience – although very important to him and his family – is not critical to the inquiry,” he added.
A spokesman for North Korea’s Association for Human Rights Studies said on Wednesday that Shin’s admissions “self-exposed” the flimsy foundations of efforts to censure Pyongyang for its rights record.
In a statement carried by the North’s official KCNA news agency, the spokesman noted that Shin was one of the best-known defectors who testified to Kirby’s panel.
The commission’s conclusion that North Korea was committing human rights violations “without parallel in the contemporary world” was the basis of a resolution adopted by the UN general assembly last month. It urged the security council to consider referring Pyongyang to the international criminal court (ICC).
The North Korean spokesman said Shin’s recent retractions proved that the commission’s report was “a false document cooked up on the basis of false testimonies made by human scum”.
“So, needless to say, all the resolutions on human rights forcibly adopted against [North Korea] on the basis of such false documents are invalid,” he added.
The UN security council held its first-ever discussion on North Korea’s rights record in December, but any referral to the ICC would almost certainly be vetoed by permanent members China and Russia.
The North has repeatedly sought to discredit Shin as a fabulist and criminal, and last October aired a TV interview with his father who called Shin a liar” and denied the family was even in a labour camp.
Shin said his father must have been coerced into denouncing him.
For activists within the North Korean defector community, Shin’s admissions of inaccuracies in his survivor story are a genuine blow, given his high profile.
North Korea’s inaccessibility makes it hard to verify individual defector accounts of their lives in the reclusive state, placing a lot of weight on their personal credibility.
Shin was something of an activist poster-boy, giving speeches around the world, penning editorials and picking up awards.
The US-based Human Rights Watch described him as the world’s “single strongest voice on atrocities taking place in North Korea”.
Shin has acknowledged that the damage his retractions have done meant he “may not be able to continue” his activist work.
In his statement, Kirby was protective of the 32-year-old defector. “Mr Shin bears, on his body, the evidence of torture and suffering. At this stage he needs help and support, not hounding,” he said.
Read 686 times
Rate this item
(0 votes)
Login to post comments
Post-Brexit talks: We'll find
The head of the UK's unions has warned Boris Johnson she
Five dead in Milwaukee
Five people have been killed in a shooting at the Molson
Trump names VP Pence to lead
President Donald Trump has appointed Vice-President Mike
Post-Brexit talks: UK
The UK has warned the EU it will walk away from trade talks
Coronavirus: Two new cases
Two more patients have tested positive for coronavirus in
Greek protests: Dozens hurt
More than 60 people have been hurt, many of them riot
Budget 2020: Chancellor must
The new chancellor must raise taxes in his first Budget or
Health officials: Coronavirus
Health officials in the US have warned Americans to brace


A man has been
Researchers say
A law introducing
US scientists are
The Yazidi

Hot News

Featured photos and videos

One show at Paris Fashion Week proved to be
Saudi Arabia has temporarily halted the entry of
Taylor Swift plays a man-spreading, cigar
Five people have been killed in a shooting at the
President Donald Trump has appointed
Two more patients have tested positive for
More than 60 people have been hurt, many of them
At least 20 civilians, including nine children,
Template Settings


For each color, the params below will give default values
Black Blue Brow Green Cyan


Background Color
Text Color
Layout Style
Select menu
Google Font
Body Font-size
Body Font-family